A 2025 Guide to Vegan Leather vs Genuine Leather

Vegan leather vs genuine leather is a conversation that we've been having for years now, and still it seems like it's impossible to find a direct answer.

On one hand, you've got the classic, timeless allure of traditional leather. On the other hand, there's vegan leather, a synthetic leather that's slowly but steadily gaining popularity about eco-conscious consumers.

So, what's the real difference between these two? Let's talk about it here.

What is Genuine Leather?

Before, genuine leather was known only as leather. It refers to a type of material made from animal hides – a byproduct of the livestock industry. The most common is cow skin, but it can also be goat, sheep, snake, and even crocodile.

For centuries, it was touted as a sustainable material. After all, animal skin used to be considered trash among other animal products. But because of leather production, the wastage can be minimized.

In order to become wearable, though, these natural materials still need to go through a complex tanning and dyeing process. This process is also quite harmful to the environment.

What is Vegan Leather?

Vegan leather is a type of leather material that doesn't use actual animal skin. Instead, it uses artificial or plant products. It's a great leather alternative for people who are going for a more sustainable lifestyle.

Technically speaking, the term vegan leather refers to any fake leather product.

That said, there are some distinctions to be made. For instance, people consider full vegan leather as faux leather made from plant-based materials like cork, fruits like apple peels, and pineapple leaves.

Meanwhile, semi-vegan refers to materials made from non-animal leather but not necessary all plant-based. For example, plastic materials like polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and polyurethane (PU) can be referred to as semi-vegan since they don't use animal skin. Our products here at Grace's Bags fall under this category as well since we use high-quality synthetic leather that's guaranteed cruelty-free.

What’s the Difference Between Vegan Leather vs Genuine Leather?

Vegan leather and genuine leather may look similar at first glance, but their differences do go far beyond appearances.

Production Process

First of all, synthetic materials like the ones we use here at Grace's Bags have a different production process than natural materials. Producing real leather starts with the meat industry. Here, animal hides that are of no use to the food industry are taken to become usable elsewhere – such as leather.

The next step is leather tanning, which uses both synthetic chemicals like chromium and natural vegetable tannins to treat the hides. Because of how intensive it is, it's typically the most environmentally unfriendly part of the process.

On the other hand, making vegan leather skips animal skins altogether. Some versions use plastic-based products like PU leather or plastic leather, while others rely on plant-based systems like cactus or pineapple leather.

Environmental Impact

The leather industry heavily relies on natural resources and is tied to deforestation, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution from the tanning process. To make animal skin wearable, it needs to undergo a very intensive process first. Fossil fuels are often used in raising livestock, adding to the problem.

As for faux leather, well, it eliminates the need for animal hides and reduces reliance on the meat industry.

That said, they're not all perfect either. Plastic leather and synthetic options can contribute to microplastic pollution, while plant-based systems may require significant agricultural resources.

So again, this all boils down to supporting a brand with a clear supply chain – that way, you know you can trust them when it comes to making sustainable products. Here on Grace's Bags, for instance, we want to be transparent about our leather bags, which are proudly cruelty-free and sustainable.

Durability and Aging

Real leather ages gracefully. It often develops a wrinkled texture and patina over time. It’s durable and can last for decades when maintained with a clean cloth and occasional care.

High-quality leather alternatives like plant-based or recycled options, meanwhile, are on the road to improving. Thanks to technilogy, they're getting better and better as time goes by.

However, low-quality synthetic plastic leather may not hold up as well or develop the same character as animal leather. So, it's important that you choose your products well. Opt for brands like Grace's Bags that use high quality synthetic leather to be 100% certain that you're getting the bang for your buck.

Ethics

Here at Grace's Bags, we often hold the position of, "Ethics is personal." And we mean it. What's ethical to you may not be ethical to me, or to her, or to him.

However, it is true that many people question the ethics of using animal skins – even when they're being marketed as a byproduct of the food industry. After all, the leather industry by itself is a billion-dollar industry. While leather may have started out as a byproduct, it's impossible to say now that it's not a valuable resource in itself.

Vegan leather offers a more ethical path forward. Of course, the best choice depends on your values—be it sustainability, style, or compassion.

But at the end of the day, if you're given two options that are both high quality but one comes at the expense of human beings... the question will always be: which one would you choose?

Real Leather vs Vegan Leather: Which is Right for You?

So, which one is right for you, exactly? Is it real leather, which has reigned for decades, or vegan leather, which is only starting to make waves?

You should choose real leather if...

For one, you may love that classic look. Maybe you wear a real leather jacket with boyish jeans.

Some companies use vegetable tanned leather for a gentler approach. That method relies on vegetable tanning, which reduces harsh chemicals. Groups like the Leather Working Group want better standards. Still, not all designers follow those guidelines. You'll need to do your own research – like looking up unbiased Grace's Bags reviews, for instance – to know where a brand stands.

Also, real leather can last a long time if treated well. It may soften with natural life and develop a worn charm. A damp cloth can clean off small scuffs, which is handy.

You should choose vegan leather if...

You care about the planet. This can be done in more ways than one. Some people now embrace a vegan diet. They also switch to vegan shoes or a vegan leather product.

This change grew over the past few decades. You might see brands – like Grace's Bags – producing vegan leather in new ways.

Of course, as mentioned above, vegan leather production often uses plastic based materials. That can mean micro plastic pollution. However, not all vegan leather has the same impact. Some rely on recycled plastic or plant fibers. A sustainable designer might skip petroleum and focus on cork or pineapple.

Does vegan leather offer durability? Many blends do, yet quality varies. There are many misconceptions about vegan leather, so always remember that the manufacturing process matters as well. Some producers use fewer chemicals or harmful toxins.

As you can see, both sides have pros and cons. You decide what feels right for your lifestyle. The choice is yours. Just weigh your priorities and shop wisely.

The Future of Faux Leather vs Genuine Leather

Leather decisions aren't black and white. Real or vegan, each has strengths. Consider impact, lifespan, and comfort. Then choose the one that fits your ideals.

It's not as simple as saying that one type of leather is wrong or right. A practical view helps you stand by your values. There's no single answer – only the option that suits you best. And here at Grace's Bags, we certainly hope we'll be your choice. Shop our collections today.

FAQs

1. Will real leather stretch after regular use?

Yes, it often does. Some folks see that as a perk. Natural fibers relax, giving shoes or jackets a looser fit. You can slow it by storing items properly. Light conditioning helps maintain shape. If things get too roomy, consider inserts or professional advice before they stretch beyond comfort.

2. Does vegan leather come in unique finishes or patterns?

Yes, it can. Some brands experiment with cork or fruit fibers. Others, like Grace's Bags, blend recycled plastic for smooth or textured surfaces. You might find glossy, matte, or embossed versions. Each option can have distinct qualities. That variety keeps the market creative and interesting. Many shoppers love that.

3. Can I wear vegetable tanned leather in rainy weather without problems?

You can, but be careful. Water seeps into the pores and may cause stiffness or mold. Light rain often isn’t a huge issue. Dry items gently if they get soaked. Protective sprays can help. Frequent moisture can weaken the hide. Regular checks and proper care make a difference.

4. Are vegan leather coats warm enough for chilly days?

Many coats feature padding or thick linings. Those layers bring extra warmth without using animal hides. Some brands add wind-resistant shells, which help in cold winds. Water-resistant surfaces also make a difference if it drizzles. Check a coat’s insulation level if you’re planning to wear it in deeper cold.

5. Are Grace's Bags products vegan leather?

Absolutely. We don't use any actual animal skins in any of our products. Our leather is 100% cruelty-free. We also source from sustainable suppliers to make sure that we can remain eco-friendly.